| 1959 – Virginia Flynn | 1988 – Alex Riccio |
| 1960 – Frances Herschkowitz | 1989 – Volunteer Needed |
| 1961 – Robert Lilenthal | 1990 – Joseph Adago |
| 1962 – Volunteer Needed | 1991 – Bronwen O’Keefe |
| 1963 – Diana Smith | 1992 – Joshua Weinman |
| 1964 – Corinne Spingarn | 1993 – Senna Riahi |
| 1965 – Berndt Krebs | 1994 – Debbie DiCastro Barker |
| 1966 – Volunteer Needed | 1995 – Ron Passaro |
| 1967 – Gregory Moore | 1996 – Jonathan Edwards |
| 1968 – Daniel Szekely | 1997 – Victoria Sander |
| 1969 – Anne Powell | 1998 – Volunteer Needed |
| 1970 – Corinne Denlinger | 1999 – Volunteer Needed |
| 1971 – Ihor Radysh | 2000 – Sarah Hearn |
| 1972 – Valerie Daniel | 2001 – Volunteer Needed |
| 1973 – Julia Hays | 2002 – Volunteer Needed |
| 1974 – Suzanne Gregoire | 2003 – Volunteer Needed |
| 1975 – Carmen Laube | 2004 – Ariel Pellman |
| 1976 – Lisa Safir-Barness | 2005 – Volunteer Needed |
| 1977 – David Klein | 2006 – Volunteer Needed |
| 1978 – Hallie Robbins | 2007 – Robert Elliot |
| 1979 – Deborah Winer | 2008 – Victoria Coverdale |
| 1980 -Nancy Thomson | 2009 – Volunteer Needed |
| 1980 – Mary Ellen Lawrence (Grill) | 2010 – Alana Kadison |
| 1981 – Lisa Davis | 2010 – Danielle Miller |
| 1982 – Antoinette Zelig | 2011 – Jeremy Martin |
| 1983 – Volunteer Needed | 2012 – Benjamin Trachtenberg |
| 1984 – Naomi McCann | 2013 – Volunteer Needed |
| 1985 – Volunteer Needed | 2014 – Lillian Gustin-Geiger |
| 1986 – Carmel Benson | |
| 1986 – Raven Metzner | |
| 1987 – David Nadel |